With 60% of Canadian mortgages set to come up for renewal within the next three years, homeowners are facing a “payment shock” unless interest rates come down in a significant way, according to the Royal Bank of Canada.
By 2026, when C$400 billion ($290 billion) worth of mortgages are set to renew — a figure that includes a large proportion of so-called negatively amortizing loans — the increase in monthly payments could be as high as 48% on a weighted average basis, RBC Capital Markets analyst Darko Mihelic, said in a report Monday.
“We believe a significant number of mortgages are coming due in the next three years” and “that payment shock (the increase in payment at renewal) could be significant and represents a tail risk to Canadian banks,” he wrote. “Unless there are significant declines in interest rates, we believe that credit losses will inevitably rise, perhaps significantly in 2025 and beyond.”
Mihelic predicts lower — but still significant — payment shocks of 32% next year, when more than C$186 billion of mortgages are set to renew, and 33% in 2025, when about C$315 billion of home loans will come up for renewal.
If the Bank of Canada’s overnight rate, which is now at 5%, comes down by 100 basis points, that would reduce the payment shock in 2024 and 2025 to about 22% or 23%, according to the report.
However the cohort renewing in 2026 is likely to face the biggest challenges. That’s when a significant portion of variable-rate mortgages with fixed monthly payments are set to renew. Those borrowers have continued to make the same monthly payments as interest rates have gone up, but in many cases are now paying only interest each month, extending the length of time it would take them to pay off the loans — also known as negatively amortizing. When they renew, they will face much higher monthly payments.
“Variable-rate mortgagors are set to see significant payment shock, perhaps as high as 84% by 2026 if interest rates do not decline,” Mihelic wrote. “Interest rates would need to decline significantly to ‘save’ this cohort.”
To reduce payment shock to 20% for the entire variable-rate cohort, for example, the Bank of Canada overnight rate would need to fall to 0.25% by July 2026, which Mihelic said is “perhaps an unreasonable expectation at the moment.”
On top of the pain for borrowers, the dynamic creates a challenging environment for the domestic retail businesses at Canada’s large banks. RBC Capital Markets is maintaining its “tepid” forecast for revenue growth of about 4% in 2024 and about 3% in 2025 for retail banking in the country.
“We believe mortgage payment shock will likely impact loan/revenue growth, mortgage delinquency (though modestly) and losses on other forms of credit,” Mihelic said. But “Canadian banks are not sitting still and being rather proactive to reduce payment shock for their customers, which could have a significant impact.”
Lenders are working with clients to get them to increase their monthly payments now, make lump-sum payments, extend the length of their loans or switch from variable-rate mortgages to fixed-rate loans, he said.
By 2026, when C$400 billion ($290 billion) worth of mortgages are set to renew — a figure that includes a large proportion of so-called negatively amortizing loans — the increase in monthly payments could be as high as 48% on a weighted average basis, RBC Capital Markets analyst Darko Mihelic, said in a report Monday.
“We believe a significant number of mortgages are coming due in the next three years” and “that payment shock (the increase in payment at renewal) could be significant and represents a tail risk to Canadian banks,” he wrote. “Unless there are significant declines in interest rates, we believe that credit losses will inevitably rise, perhaps significantly in 2025 and beyond.”
Mihelic predicts lower — but still significant — payment shocks of 32% next year, when more than C$186 billion of mortgages are set to renew, and 33% in 2025, when about C$315 billion of home loans will come up for renewal.
If the Bank of Canada’s overnight rate, which is now at 5%, comes down by 100 basis points, that would reduce the payment shock in 2024 and 2025 to about 22% or 23%, according to the report.
However the cohort renewing in 2026 is likely to face the biggest challenges. That’s when a significant portion of variable-rate mortgages with fixed monthly payments are set to renew. Those borrowers have continued to make the same monthly payments as interest rates have gone up, but in many cases are now paying only interest each month, extending the length of time it would take them to pay off the loans — also known as negatively amortizing. When they renew, they will face much higher monthly payments.
“Variable-rate mortgagors are set to see significant payment shock, perhaps as high as 84% by 2026 if interest rates do not decline,” Mihelic wrote. “Interest rates would need to decline significantly to ‘save’ this cohort.”
To reduce payment shock to 20% for the entire variable-rate cohort, for example, the Bank of Canada overnight rate would need to fall to 0.25% by July 2026, which Mihelic said is “perhaps an unreasonable expectation at the moment.”
On top of the pain for borrowers, the dynamic creates a challenging environment for the domestic retail businesses at Canada’s large banks. RBC Capital Markets is maintaining its “tepid” forecast for revenue growth of about 4% in 2024 and about 3% in 2025 for retail banking in the country.
“We believe mortgage payment shock will likely impact loan/revenue growth, mortgage delinquency (though modestly) and losses on other forms of credit,” Mihelic said. But “Canadian banks are not sitting still and being rather proactive to reduce payment shock for their customers, which could have a significant impact.”
Lenders are working with clients to get them to increase their monthly payments now, make lump-sum payments, extend the length of their loans or switch from variable-rate mortgages to fixed-rate loans, he said.